Breast Cancer

“Lifestyle choices may increase or decrease the risk of breast cancer, but that knowledge is an opportunity to empower ourselves, not to blame” – Dean Ornish, MD.

Breast cancer evokes more fear than cardiovascular disease, even though cardiovascular disease is the leading cause of death in women. Perhaps it’s because breast cancer seems more random and often strikes at an earlier age. Observational studies have found many dietary factors to be associated with an increase or decrease in long term breast cancer mortality.

The following resources are intended to empower women to reduce their life-time risk of dying from breast cancer. It is not our intention to explain why anyone has developed breast cancer as such thinking can lead to blame and guilt – we think this is the reason why health organisations and specialists are reluctant to tell women what dietary changes will reduce their risk.

Prevention
The association between the Western diet and breast cancer has been known for many years.

Correlation between per capita consumption of animal fat and age-adjusted mortality from breast cancer in different countries (Source: Carroll, 1975, Cancer Research, 35:3379)

Correlation between per capita consumption of animal fat and age-adjusted mortality from breast cancer in different countries (Source: Carroll, 1975, Cancer Research, 35:3379)

This classic graph of breast cancer vs fat intake shows a wide variance in breast cancer risk between countries, demonstrating that that rising breast cancer risk with age is not inevitable.

This graph probably tells a much broader story, the fat intake being a marker for an increased intake of animal products and a reduced intake of whole plant foods. There are other lifestyle factors: breast cancer risk is increased by early puberty, obesity and alcohol; and decreased by younger age of first pregnancy, breast feeding and exercise. Studies of migrant populations prove that genes do not explain the variation between countries.

By late middle age, most women will have breast micro-cancers. At this stage, and probably at a much earlier age, the strategies we present to help you to prevent breast cancer might actually be regarded as “treatment” to keep those cancers micro-sized.

Screening
It may surprise some of you that there is a great deal of controversy about whether breast screening mammography is beneficial. There are several points to be made:

  • Earlier discovery of breast cancer will only sometimes change the long term outcome
  • As many as a third of breast cancers found by screening programs would not have progressed to clinical disease
  • Many women are physically and mentally harmed by further investigation and treatment of false positive results – lesions that turn out not to be breast cancer.

The video by Goetsch gives an excellent overview of this: Peter Gøtzsche, MD: Director of The Nordic Cochrane Centre: Part 1: Recommends against mammography and prostate cancer screening

The decision on whether or not to undergo breast screening is a personal one. Most doctors would recommend screening for women considered to be at greatly increased risk.

Treatment
Conventional treatments include surgery, radiotherapy, chemotherapy and long-term hormonal treatment. The benefits of some of these therapies may be overstated. It is important to ask your oncologist what the absolute risk reduction is for the particular treatment, i.e. the likelihood that an individual will avoid premature death. A low-fat, high-fibre plant-based diet has been shown to improve overall survival following breast cancer diagnosis (McEligot et al 2006; Xing et al 2014). The evidence is strong enough such that it should be routine to recommend a whole foods plant-based diet alongside conventional cancer treatment. It should be appreciated that cancer survivors are at increased risk of other diseases, especially heart disease – which can be prevented with a whole foods plant-based diet.

There are many case reports of prolonged remission of advanced breast cancer through adoption of a whole foods plant-based lifestyle. Randomised controlled trials have demonstrated that low to medium grade prostate cancer can be treated with diet alone, but similar trials have not been conducted for breast cancer (for ethical reasons). We look forward to future trials which will investigate the impact of a whole foods, plant-based diet on breast cancer survival, although we note that the prostate cancer research findings have been ignored.

While medical experts are waiting for “gold standard” randomised controlled trials before they make any dietary recommendations for breast cancer, we consider there is enough evidence to act now. The side effects of a whole food plant-based diet are all good – improved overall wellness and ability to cope with treatment protocols, prevention and reversal of other chronic diseases and empowerment to take control of your destiny.

Resources

Web links:

Videos:

Peer-reviewed articles:

See also:

Success stories

Page created 30 November 2013
Last updated 27 November 2016

Cancer

There is good evidence that a whole foods plant based diet will reduce the incidence and slow the progression of the most common cancers, including: bowel, breast and prostate cancers. Increased vegetable intake has also been shown to reduce the risk of skin cancer and lung cancer. This knowledge is intended to help you prevent the growth of cancer and should in no way be used as an explanation as to why you, or anyone else developed cancer. We do not recommend that a plant based diet replace conventional treatment, rather it should be used alongside conventional treatment.

Besides anecdotal reports of individual cancer remissions, there is evidence that lifestyle changes can slow the progression of cancer and increase survival rates. Dr Dean Ornish (2005) showed that intensive lifestyle intervention, including a plant based diet, controlled the progression of low-grade prostate cancer. Dr Michael Greger discusses the study in this video: Cancer Reversal Through Diet? Survival following treatment for breast cancer has been well studied. Higher intakes of saturated fats from animal products are associated with reduced survival whereas high fibre intakes from plant foods are protective.

Animal protein is the elephant in the room in relation to diet and cancer. The evidence linking animal protein to cancer does not sit comfortably with our long-standing paradigm that places high protein meat and dairy foods at the centre of our diet. Dr T. Colin Campbell has been a world-renowned researcher in this area for over forty years.  He describes milk protein, casein as the most relevant chemical carcinogen ever identified. See his talk Animal Protein — Meat and Dairy — Cause Cancer  (45 mins):

There is a wealth of resources regarding the links between diet and cancer. We have tried to select some of the best and most significant but the list is by no means complete.

Resources

Books

Videos

PCRM (Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine) have developed a comprehensive list of resources for understanding the link between nutrition and cancer:

Web links

Peer-reviewed articles

Alcohol


Specific cancers

  • Breast Cancer
  • Colon Cancer (under construction)
  • Prostate Cancer (under construction)

Success stories

Page created 21 January 2013
Last updated 28 November 2016